I had a chance to watch Hillbilly: The
Real Story the other day after missing the first two airings.
As a propagandist for the “hill folk”
I can't complain too much since its intent was to be sympathetic but
if I had a couple of million dollars lying around with which to make
a documentary about the Appalachian people I would have done things a
bit differently. For the most part it was factual and the more
important the topic the more accurate they seemed to be.
I do think that they made some poor
choices on editing. They begin the two hour program with a segment on
moonshine after only the slightest mention about how Appalachians are
misrepresented. To be honest moonshine is a far better item of
introduction than coal but I still think I would have gone to the
Scottish border wars first off. My guess is that the producers
wanted to set the stage by displaying the hillbilly as both self
reliant and resistant to what they see as unfair governance.
Moonshine and the Whiskey Rebellion are perfect as a hub to
illustrate this point. They must be given credit for stating that
the hillbillies did not “invent” moonshine in the hills of
Appalachia but brought it with them from Northern Ireland. Indeed
today whiskey is so common a spirit that we tend to see it as a
universal but whiskey or uisce beatha
which means water of life in Gaelic is an Irish/ Scottish spirit and
was even more so then. The importance of pointing out that the
new settlers to Appalachia brought their whiskey with them is that it
illustrates an older heritage and a heritage that was already
separate from the rest of the rum drinking colonies.
The following segment on marijuana
is unfortunate but true and does follow somewhat the pattern of the
moonshiners. I am more inclined to accept this comparison than any between moonshiners and crystal meth production. Given that
marijuana is not a dangerous drug in and of
itself other than causing the habitual user to waste his life it is
not surprising that hillbillies would be more inclined to turn a
blind eye to its production as stated by this portion of the
program. The problem as the police officers illustrate is that these
dope growers resort to violent tactics to protect their crop which is
often grown in remote patches on public lands such as national
forests.
One difference between the classic
battle between the revenuers and the moonshiners is that the
anti-drug officers are often local people. As stated by one of the
officers interviewed, these hollers and hills are home to these
police officers and where their children are being raised. They have
a vested interest in eradicating this blight. One truth that was not
mentioned that I know from my personal experience is that the drug
producers are often outsiders. These outside criminals move into the
area and corrupt locals to make use of their knowledge of the
community and geography. As Billy Ray says an average household
income of less than $8,000 a year makes such activity much more
tempting than it would be otherwise.
In the next section of the program the
producers examine the origin of the Appalachian people. I was
pleased to see that they take the high road and go with the truth
instead of the politically correct, multi-cultural garbage that is
popular in our universities. The hillbilly culture has its origin in
the borderlands of Scotland and England starting in the 13th
century. The constant battles and strife of the area caused a clan
society to develop. As Senator Jim Webb explains this type of
uncertainty leads individuals to form bonds with those closest to
them and on their level.
Starting in 1610 the Scottish King
James the VII who became James I of Great Britain thought that he
could kill two birds with one stone and send many of these rough
lowland Scots to Northern Ireland. This would relieve the population
pressures on largely infertile southern Scotland and send a force to
“pacify” the native Irish. Many of facts surrounding the
plantation of Northern Ireland are glossed over in this segment but
what facts are there are accurate. The program does not mention the
religious persecution of the Presbyterians
by the Anglican Church of Ireland.
The show accurately describes how a
quarter of a million people from Northern Ireland settled in the back
country of America in a short period of time. The bulk of these
settled between 1750 and 1775. There is no mention of James Logan,
the Scots-Irish, Quaker and secretary for the Penn family. Logan is
largely responsible for the settlement of the Scots-Irish into
western Pennsylvania. He stated explicitly in a letter that he hoped
the Ulster Scots could act as a “human frontier” between the
passive Quakers in the east and the native “savages” in the west.
This program is sympathetic to the Scots-Irish settlers concerning
the Indian Wars but it makes no mention that they were performing a
bloody task that they were specifically recruited for.
Although they do not use the exact
words the program makes clear that before long the Scots-Irish become
the new “savages” gaining much knowledge of surviving in the back
country from their enemies the Native Americans. Eventually this
knowledge of guerrilla warfare would help
them turn the war in favor of the American rebels. Perhaps too much
time is spent on the single Battle of King's Mountain, but it is by
far the most famous battle won by the new Appalachians.
Interestingly the British force that the Over-mountain Men defeated
at King's Mountain were largely Scottish Highlanders. Also a fact not mentioned.
There is no mention however of Sargent
York Syndrome which would have fit perfectly into this segment. This
syndrome which was coined by a Veterans' Hospital physician in
Tennessee, describes the phenomena of Appalachia having the highest
casualty rate in all of its wars up until the current Gulf War. Nor
would I expect them to delve into the horrible way in which the
government exploits the likes of both Jessica Lynch and Lynndie
English.
What many viewers probably will not
catch but is so very important at the end of this section before the
commercial break is the mention that for
the next 100 years the Appalachian culture develops separately from
the rest of the nation. This is crucial to understanding modern
Appalachian and her hillbillies. We did not degenerate from the same
basic British culture as the rest of the country; we were different
from the beginning. We came from a different branch on the British
tree and naturally developed a culture that was familiar yet separate
from those other largely English communities. And this 100 years of
development took place before COAL. Hillbillies were hillbillies
before coal.
The next segment starts with an account of the local color writers. Certainly the local color writers of
the mid-19th century are a bunch who have to be rotting in
Hell. More than any single group including the robber barons, the
local color writers so degraded the people of Appalachia that the
unscrupulous industrialist were able to mistreat the citizens of the
hills without fear that the nation at large would be sympathetic to
the plight of the hill folk. These same industrialist often owned
the publications in which these lurid tales appeared. Go figure.
Poor and uneducated Appalachian farmers were swindled out of land or
gave up timber and mineral rights for pennies on the dollar only to
be left with poisoned wells and ruined moonscapes that took
generations to heal. The Industrial Revolution has come and gone and
with it the economic benefits, but the negative stereotypes still
survive.
From the local color articles to the
railroad, coal mines and independent Christian churches the program
by way of the most notable examples such as the Clinch Valley Line,
Matewan and the Battle of Blair Mountain and snake handling
highlights some of Appalachia's famous and peculiar elements. One
may be quick to point out that these are single examples of very
common items in Appalachia but I assume that the Moore-Huntley
production team's focus is taking on these “well known”
Appalachian elements and demystifying them.
Many areas of Appalachia were always
open to the rest of the nation. Travelers going from east to west
would have a very long detour if they did not cross Appalachia by
many of her gaps and passes, stopping at the many Appalachian
villages and towns that serviced these roads and early rails. But
railroads like the Clinch did open up Appalachia to the industrial
age and no doubt advanced the building of rail lines into most every
county in the region. The railroad made coal possible and coal made
the railroad possible. The industrial revolution also brought new
people to Appalachia from Italy and eastern Europe.
I have often wondered if the Battle of
Blair Mountain could have happened in any other region of the nation
at that time. Certainly the wild west witnessed similar violence
only a generation prior but in the 20thcentury, I doubt
that the public would have tolerated company guards dropping bombs on
or machine gunning citizens in New England. I reckon the same
factors tahat allowed the Battle of Blair Mountain to take place allows MIC to be produced at Institute, WV next to the campus of
WVSU.
There were many conflicts between the
labor unions and the mine owners in Appalachia and the legal battles go
even today but Matewan and the Battle of Blair Mountain are certainly the best known and perhaps the most egregious
examples of industrial arrogance besides the lesser known Hawk's Nest
disaster.
Most controversial is the segment on
snake handlers. Here the producers do a masterful job of making the
members of this religious sect look rational while being clear that
most Appalachians do not practice or even condone this ritual. As a
hillbilly it distresses me that West Virginia is the only state where
snake handling is legal. And this is the point. Appalachia is full
of little cinder clock churches. Billy Ray tells us that there are
80 different Baptist denominations alone. As one interviewee
explains, if a group of folks doesn't like what is being preached at
their current church they will just up and build another little
church down the road.
Religious freedom was one of the
reasons for the Scots-Irish ending up in these hills. The program
does mention the tent revivals of the 18th century but
does not call them as such and does not go into detail about the New
Light and Appalachians transformation from Presbyterianism
to Baptist and Methodist sects.
All of these little white washed
churches stand in stark contrast to the suburban mega-churches in the
rest of the country. I have sincere doubts as to whether any of
those little churches fund political action committees. I would rather risk my life by handling a copperhead than risk my soul by shaking hands with the pastor of a mega-church.
From the pious little churches the
program turns to the moonshine runners who became the proto-stock car
drivers. The motor sport born in
Appalachian Georgia that would become NASCAR may have mutated
into something that the foreigners watch but I sleep better at night
knowing that there are still dirt tracks out there like Lavonia
Speedway in Georgia and my hometown track Portsmouth Raceway.
I reckon the next segment on the TVA
illustrates the bittersweet realities of progress in our region. I
am a proud Luddite, but I am not about to get all Amish on anyone. I
like electric stuff and I like good paying jobs that make that stuff.
When the reservoir was filled and those
Appalachian communities were flooded they were lost true enough, but
anytime we allow the outside world to come in so that we can have
jobs we risk losing a bit of our community. That said I can remember
when the steel mills, shoe factories and the nuclear enrichment plant
were all still in production in Portsmouth, Ohio. There were 40,000
more hillbillies and their friends living in that little river city
then and the Waltons could not have been more Appalachian than my
family in 1969.
As dangerous as it may be to welcome
job producing industry into our Appalachian communities it is far
more dangerous to allow our children to leave in order to find work
outside of the region. Without alternatives we have to rely on
destructive extraction industry or we end up with a population of old
folks and trash and the few folks in the service industry that any community needs such as hospital workers, teachers and other government
types. The producers don't say it out right but even a place as
beautiful as Appalachia with workers as brave as coal miners need an
infusion of industry to survive.
Appropriately Billy Ray states that
perhaps the greatest gift that the hillbillies have given to the
nation (and the world) is our music. We have transformed the Celtic
folk music we brought with us 300 years ago into a global art form.
I may bristle at the pop-with-a-cowboy-hat that dominates America's
airwaves but I have to admit no small bit of satisfaction that it may
be watered down but it is mine. I can't expect everyone to be into
John Prine or Dwight Yoakam.
I think the producers were also
brilliant in drafting Billy Ray Cyrus as the narrator. Of course I
cheer for Billy Ray as a fellow tristate boy, but Billy Ray is a
living example of the hillbilly spirit. From the moment he gained
national attention he was a target of ridicule for his mullet. But
Billy Ray didn't let that stop him. He had a nice little show, kind
of an anti-House, called “Doc” where he plays a kindly country
doctor in the big city. He started a charity for the needy children
of the Ashland-Ironton area. And now his daughter, Miley is the biggest
star Disney has with her show, Hannah Montana in which Billy Ray
plays her dad. Let's just keep her away from some of the other
former Disney stars.
So Hillbilly: The Real Story gets
a Rednecromancer thumbs up. It could have been more in depth but it
would have had to have been longer which would have probably
precluded it from showing up on the light weight History Channel.
The facts for the most part were accurate ( the battle of Blair
Mountain was NOT the origin of redneck ) and some of the most
important issues were addressed. It was biased in favor of
hillbillies but that is just fine since we have years of
anti-hillbilly bias to make up for.
The important statements made by the
program are that hillbillies have a pre-American origin and that we
have developed separately and not degenerated. And while we are a
separate American culture we have contributed greatly to the overall
American experience.
Or at least the most important items.
Freedom, loyalty, country music, etc,
etc